If you bet NFL props and aren’t checking which sportsbook gives the best prop odds, you’re likely leaving money on the table. In 2025, with sharper lines and more data-driven platforms than ever before, the edge comes from shopping not just lines, but the actual prices behind those lines.
This isn’t just about who has player props. Everyone does. It’s about who consistently posts odds that put you in a +EV (positive expected value) position. Whether you’re betting over 53.5 rushing yards or taking a longshot TD scorer, the odds determine your upside and survivability.
We ran a full-season test across the 2024 NFL slate, analyzing prop odds from FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM, Caesars, Bet365, and PrizePicks (adjusted for fixed-odds parity). The results? Eye-opening.
Let’s dig into who had the best prop odds — and how you can use this knowledge to make smarter, sharper NFL bets all season.
Methodology: How We Tested for the Best Prop Odds
To ensure a clean, unbiased comparison, we tracked and analyzed prop odds across 75 NFL games during the 2024 season, focusing on core player prop categories:
- Rushing yards
- Receiving yards
- Passing yards
- Touchdowns (anytime scorer)
- Receptions
- Interceptions thrown
- Completions
Each week, we scraped and recorded prop lines and odds 24 hours before kickoff across six sportsbooks:
- FanDuel
- DraftKings
- BetMGM
- Caesars
- Bet365
- PrizePicks (converted implied odds using 2-pick payouts)
We then scored each book based on:
- Average odds quality (measured by comparing best/worst prices per player prop)
- Frequency of having the best line or price
- Consistency across positions and bet types
- Market availability and posting time
- Limits and adjustability for sharp users
This wasn’t about affiliate deals or bonus offers. This was purely a value-based test to find out where the best prop odds live in 2025.
The Results: Which Sportsbook Had the Best Prop Odds?
Here’s how each sportsbook performed, from best to worst, based on our value index across all core prop types.
1. Bet365: The Value King for NFL Props
Win Rate for Best Odds: 34.7%
Notable Strength: Passing and receiving yardage props
Weak Spot: TD scorer odds are less competitive
Bet365 came out on top in our test, narrowly edging out FanDuel thanks to sharper pricing and better availability on lesser-known props. Their lines often moved later, allowing savvy bettors to get ahead of movement seen on more popular books.
We also noticed Bet365 was less aggressive with juice. Where FanDuel or DraftKings were pricing overs at -122, Bet365 would often be sitting at -110 or even +100 in some edge cases.
For example, in Week 9:
- Stefon Diggs o/u 78.5 receiving yards
- FanDuel: Over -118 / Under -108
- Bet365: Over -105 / Under -115
That 13-cent difference might not seem like much, but over a season of volume betting, it’s massive.
Verdict: If you’re serious about getting the best price on most NFL props, Bet365 is the sharpest weapon in your wallet right now.
2. FanDuel: Best for Longshot Props and Early Markets
Win Rate for Best Odds: 32.9%
Notable Strength: Anytime TD and first TD scorer markets
Weak Spot: Juice-heavy on overs
FanDuel is the king of creativity. From alt rushing props to obscure combo bets, their menu is unmatched. But what really stood out in 2025 was their favorable longshot pricing.
Anytime TD lines often came in 10–15 points higher than DraftKings or BetMGM.
Example, Week 14:
- James Cook Anytime TD
- DraftKings: +115
- FanDuel: +135
- BetMGM: +110
That’s a 17% increase in payout potential for the exact same outcome.
FanDuel also posts props early in the week, giving bettors time to build correlated parlays before lines adjust.
Verdict: Ideal for bettors who like to shoot their shot with plus-money props or build SGPs around volatility.
3. DraftKings: Most Balanced, But Not the Best
Win Rate for Best Odds: 21.5%
Notable Strength: Receptions, completions, and attempts
Weak Spot: Aggressive juice on popular players
DraftKings props are clean, consistent, and widely available. But they often fall right in the middle of the market — rarely the best odds, rarely the worst.
Their pricing feels more data-driven, which means high-usage players like Christian McCaffrey or Tyreek Hill tend to have extremely efficient lines.
In Week 11:
- Tyreek Hill o/u 89.5 receiving yards
- DraftKings: Over -120
- Bet365: Over -108
- Caesars: Over -110
Still, DraftKings does shine on volume-based stats like completions, pass attempts, and receptions. That’s where they’re willing to hang good prices on lesser-known QBs.
Verdict: A solid second-check platform. Rarely exploitable, but valuable for line comparison and reception props.
4. Caesars: Decent Pricing, Weak Variety
Win Rate for Best Odds: 7.2%
Notable Strength: TD scorer props
Weak Spot: Inconsistent markets and late posting
Caesars didn’t win many rounds in our test, but when they did, it was usually on short-yardage TD props and obscure backups.
Their lines came out late compared to FanDuel or DK, which made them less attractive for early-week bettors. And they lacked alt-line flexibility, which cuts off strategic value-hunting.
Still, for bettors who like betting TDs or RB2/RB3 vulture plays, Caesars had some useful edges.
Verdict: Use for niche angles, but don’t rely on Caesars as your primary prop book.
5. BetMGM: Poor Value, Limited Edge
Win Rate for Best Odds: 2.8%
Notable Strength: TD scorer props
Weak Spot: High juice and low variety
BetMGM’s props were the least competitive of the major books in 2025. Odds were often 10–15 cents worse than the best available, and lines lacked flexibility.
There were few moments during the season where BetMGM offered a clear edge, though their TD markets mirrored FanDuel’s in terms of availability.
Verdict: Use only for bonus play or promo eligibility. Rarely a value destination.
6. PrizePicks: Great UX, But Poor Value
Win Rate for Best Odds (Implied): 1.1%
Notable Strength: UI, experience, and fixed lines
Weak Spot: Fixed payouts = awful long-term value
We ran PrizePicks through a conversion filter to translate 2-leg fixed payout parlays into implied single-leg odds. The results? Bleak.
While PrizePicks is fun and accessible, the platform gives bettors no edge, and often punishes them on coin-flip props. With fixed payouts of 3x for two correct picks, the implied odds on each leg are around -137.
That’s steep, especially when books like Bet365 are offering -110 on the same player and stat.
Verdict: Great for entertainment. Bad for sharp, sustainable prop betting.
Betting Smarter: How to Use Prop Odds to Your Advantage
Knowing which sportsbook has the best prop odds is one part of the puzzle. Here’s how to put that knowledge into a winning framework:
1. Always Line Shop — Even for 5-Cent Differences
Most bettors understand line shopping conceptually. But few actually build it into their process.
Consider this: A +125 line vs +115 on a 40% win probability bet has a 2.9% edge difference. That adds up fast if you’re betting multiple props per week.
Tools like Props.Cash, Betstamp, and Unabated make comparison easy, but a manual check across your top 2–3 books before locking in a prop is still worth the time.
2. Look for Overreaction Props After Prime Time Games
Players who explode on Monday Night Football often have inflated lines the following week. This is especially true for receiving yards and TD scorer props.
Fade the public spike. Example from Week 13:
- Zay Flowers exploded for 110 yards on MNF
- Next week’s line opened at 62.5 (market consensus), but Bet365 hung 68.5
- Under bettors got early value and cashed as he finished with 48
Sportsbooks know what you watched. Use that knowledge to zig when the public zags.
3. Exploit Late Injury Adjustments and Depth Charts
NFL injury news breaks late. Backups often offer prop value before lines adjust or are even posted.
Track beat writers and injury reports. When a starting RB or WR is ruled out, lesser-known books might delay adjusting backup player lines. Those 10–15 minutes are your goldmine.
Example:
- Alexander Mattison anytime TD after Dalvin Cook was scratched
- FanDuel moved from +180 to +110 in 20 minutes
- Caesars didn’t move until kickoff — Mattison scored
The best bettors win before the games start.
4. Watch Weather and Game Script — Especially for QB Props
Cold, wind, and game script impact prop value. If a team is projected to lead by 10+, fade the opposing QB’s pass attempts and completions. Conversely, garbage time overs often hit when the public bails.
Look for:
- Wind over 15mph = fade deep shots and long field goals
- Snow/heavy rain = boost rushing attempts and under receptions
- Game script (spreads >7) = fade pass volume for winning QBs
It’s not just about the player. It’s about the context.
5. Use Alt Lines Strategically
Alt lines offer higher payouts and let you lean into your conviction.
Example:
- Christian McCaffrey rushing yards
- Standard: 69.5 (-110)
- Alt 90+ yards: +190
If you project game script heavily in his favor, take the alt — especially on books like FanDuel that offer robust alt menus.
Final Verdict: Who Really Has the Best Prop Odds in 2025?
Here’s the final scoreboard from our 2025 test of best prop odds:
| Sportsbook | Best Odds Frequency | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|
| Bet365 | 34.7% | Core stat props, efficient pricing |
| FanDuel | 32.9% | Longshots, alt lines, early SGPs |
| DraftKings | 21.5% | Balanced, reception volume props |
| Caesars | 7.2% | Niche TD props, backups |
| BetMGM | 2.8% | Bonus chasers only |
| PrizePicks | 1.1% (Implied) | Casual users only |
Winner: Bet365 offers the best prop odds overall, with sharp lines and consistent value across major NFL stat categories.
But FanDuel deserves credit for innovation and longshot pricing. DraftKings remains the most stable, but lacks upside for value hunters.
One Thing to Do Before Sunday
Before you place another player prop this week, pick your top three sportsbooks, and compare prices side-by-side. Just one check per bet.
That alone can boost your ROI more than any betting system or model.
The odds don’t just matter — they define whether you’re betting for fun or betting for profit.